I keep going back and forth on the film for Batman ITTL, I apologize for the canon whiplash. Such is the danger of planning such a specific detail years in advance of the film's debut here. For now, I've changed it back to Tim Burton as the director, but kept Willem Dafoe as The Dark Knight for now.
Alright then, let's keep Willem Dafoe for a while as Bruce Wayne/Batman. You already mentioned Sean Young as Vicki Vale, Michael Gough as Alfred Pennyworth, Billy Dee Williams as Harvey Dent/Two Face, Pat Hingle as Commissioner Gordon, and Jack Palance as Rupert Thorne. We universally agree that Jack Nicholson as Jack Napier/Joker is one of his iconic performances IOTL, but I want to see Mark Hamill as Joker ITTL. He nailed the voice from Batman: The Animated Series IOTL, but I want to see him in live action, that would be amazing because he's got the energy than Nicholson did IOTL. I proposed that we keep Batman: The Movie premiered in 1984 ITTL. With Batman II later in 1987 ITTL, are we still going to keep Michelle Pfeiffer as Selina Kyle/Catwoman and Danny Devito as Oswald Cobblepot/The Penguin? For me, I would keep it as well genius. I don't know if we're going to keep Christopher Walken as Max Schreck as well, but I'll let you geniuses decide. And finally, with Batman III later in 1990 ITTL, I strongly suggest and proposed Robin Williams as The Riddler, and I've read or heard that Marlon Wayans as Robin. I don't know if we're also going to keep Uma Thurman as Poison Ivy, but I'll let you geniuses also decide. With The Original Batman Trilogy ITTL, along with The Original Superman Trilogy ITTL, we're going to have a better superhero movies than IOTL. For now, we're looking forward Mr. President on your another Special Pop Culture Chapter Update, this one is about Star Wars Episode V: The Empire Strikes Back ITTL.Thank You! Willem Dafoe is one of those actors whom I truly believe can do anything. He has such an incredible range and one of my favorites. While he's great at playing unhinged villains, I like his turns as a hero as well. I'm imagining that his take on Bruce Wayne would be a bit of his detective from American Psycho and Agent Ward from Mississippi Burning with a bit of that classic Batman angst and brooding. Though IOTL, Burton wasn't keen on including Robin/Dick Grayson, I'd like to see us try to work him in as well, maybe in time for the sequel.
Last edited: