List alternate PMs or Presidents

Status
Not open for further replies.
Star-Spangled Sky

1944-1945: Franklin D. Roosevelt/Harry S. Truman (Democratic)
1944: Thomas E. Dewey/John W. Bricker (Republican)
1945-1946: Harry S. Truman/vacant (Democratic)[1]
1946-1955: General Franklin Blake/vacant (Non-Partisan)[2]
1955-1967: Hector Lindsey/Dwight Chambers (Democratic)[3]
1954: Jordan Powell/Evan Schwartz (Republican)
1958: Jordan Powell/Lester Richardson (Republican)
1962: Irving Carroll/Cassandra Lyons (Republican)

1967-????: Irving Carroll/Laurence Frank (Republican)[4]
1966: Hector Lindsey/Dwight Chambers (Democratic), Preslav Hus/Rudy Slominsky (Slavic Socialist)[5], Rachael Wandsworth/Armon Speyer (New Zionist)[6]

[1] The German 'Ending Weapon' came out of nowhere. After long years of pointless slog in the Pacific, the Germans trampled over the ashy skeleton of Britain to rain flame down on American cities. Truman tried to stand firm, but he surrendered after Japanese soldiers began landing on the Pacific Coast. But all was not lost.
[2] The general in command of the esoteric scientific research base, Project Brooklyn, decided not to recognise the surrender, and used the technology developed under his command to flee to the Moon. He was acclaimed President, but there was no actual election. His time as President was mostly concerned with building the colony of New Washington under the lunar regolith, and preparing for a possible discovery of the base by Nazis.
[3] The election produced a powerful Democratic majority, though it ought to be noted that the labels of Democratic and Republican were rebuilt from the ground up. The Democrats had the advantage of Roosevelt's legacy, and posed the snarling grimace of the American Moon against the Nazi Earth, the dream of liberating the planet, and the eventual blossoming of human civilisation in the light of science and liberty. This compelling vision gave way after eight years of growth to a sort of tired fist-shaking, a frustration that Nazi Earth had not yet crumbled, and with a new generation of Americans having known nothing but the Moon, there was a sense of needing to relocate their priorities from staring at the Earth to looking outwards at the cosmos.
[4] Carroll presented a new vision for New Washington and the American Moon, after twelve years of Democratic plodding. Mostly keeping to the Democratic economic agenda, he rejected much of the internationalism of the Democrats, and instead proposed a new form of Manifest Destiny. They were too few to fight the Nazis, but they had a head start in space, and there they could expand and grow and succeed, just as they had on Earth.
[5] The emergence of immigrant parties was noticeable, and the largest such was the Slavic Socialist Party which mostly appealed to immigrants from the former Soviet Union, though they toned down the Communism when in New Washington.
[6] The remaining Jews were sought out by American scouts, and on the Moon they organised as the New Zionist Party. They could be a real spoiler for the Democratic voting bloc.
 
No 9/11

2001-2005: George W. Bush / Richard B. Cheney (Republican)[1]
2000: Al Gore, Jr. / Joe Lieberman (Democratic)
2005-2013: Al Gore, Jr. / Jeanne Shaheen (Democratic)[2]
2004: George W. Bush / Richard B. Cheney (Republican)
2008: George Allen / Rick Santorum (Republican) [3]

2013-2021: Tim Pawlenty / Piyush "Bobby" Jindal (Republican)[4]
2012: Jeanne Shaheen / Wesley Clark (Democratic)
2016: Andrew Cuomo / Bill Nelson (Democratic) [5]

2021-0000: Kamala Harris / Anthony Foxx (Democratic)[6]
2020: Greg Orman / Lisa Murkowski (Independent), Piyush "Bobby" Jindal / John Thune (Republican)[7]

[1] The FBI manages to avert the hijackings at the 11th hour, and the White House tries and fails to turn this failed attack into a narrative about a "War on Terror", losing both Congress and the Senate in 2002. Apart from much talk of getting rid of Saddam, the Bush quickly became a "Do-Nothing" administration unable and unwilling to do much more than feed the base and lock horns with an empowered Democratic Congress.
[2] Democratic heavyweights manage to convince Gore to run again, scraping off a strong challenge from John Edwards and coming up with a more inspiring ticket and campaign strategy. Still doesn't win Tennessee, but it was enough to secure the Democrats all both arms of the legislature. Gore's terms were marked by a strong focus on Environmentalism and rebuilding infrastructure, even after the global economy went south. He was seen as weak by many in spite of the successful assassination of Osama Bin Laden in Afghanistan in 2006 (conspiracy theorists wonder if this timing was deliberate enough to successfully secure the DNC the midterms). Car Bomb attacks in Chicago and Boston in 2009 by Al-Queda led many to question Gore's handling of the Terror. The collapsing banks in 2009-10 also damaged his credibility seriously, and his stimulus packages found themselves rapidly watered-down by the Republican Congress after 2010.
[3] The Economy was rapidly cooling down by 2008, and the GOP stood a fair chance of defeating Gore if it weren't for a car-crash campaign and a gaffe-prone ticket. Allen's off-the-cuff "macaca" remark about Illinois Governor Obama and Santorum's poorly judged defence of Allen sealed their fate.
[4] Pawlenty ran in 2012 as a "safe pair of hands" and attempted to steer clear of social issues (same-sex marriage being legal in 30 states by the November 2012) and in spite of lacking charisma, managed to defeat Rick Perry, Mike Huckabee and Mike DeWine for the nomination. His terms were marked by the (largely successful) intervention in the Lybian Civil War, education reform, pouring money into NASA and an abortive attempt to partially privatise Social Security.
[5] The recovering economy and apparent strength of Pawlenty meant that many potential candidates for the Democratic Nomination stayed away, the most prominent being Hilary Clinton, who settled with a record of Secretary of State under Gore. New York Senator Cuomo was the most "heavyweight" of the candidates and proved to be his own worst enemy in the General Election.
[6] The Democratic Establishment quickly united around California Senator Harris, who went on to easily defeat Martin O' Malley, Joaquin Castro and Mike Michaud. Her first year in office has proved to be a dynamic one, focusing on Healthcare and Tort reform and meditating on the Indian-Pakistani Nuclear Standoff.
[7] The election was Harris' to lose from the start, but the rise and rise of Kansas Governor Greg Orman threw a spanner in the works, pushing Jindal further and further to the right and draining the Democrats of support. For about two months it looked possible that he might win in the Electoral College, but the three-way debates which Harris dominated stole momentum from the Independent campaign.
 
Last edited:
Reagan 68

Ronald Reagan (1969-1977)
George H. W. Bush (1977-1985)
Bob Dole (1985-1993)

Bill Clinton (1993-2001)
John McCain (2001-2009)
Hilary Clinton (2009-2017)
 
Reagan 68

Ronald Reagan (1969-1977)
George H. W. Bush (1977-1985)
Bob Dole (1985-1993)

Bill Clinton (1993-2001)
John McCain (2001-2009)
Hilary Clinton (2009-2017)

I highly doubt the GOP would hold the White House for 25 years, and I doubt that Ronald Reagan would get elected President or even get the GOP nomination due to the fact that he was only governor of California for less than 2 years (he was elected in 1966). If Nixon didn't run in 1968, or messed up bad enough to where he would lose the nomination, Nelson Rockefeller or George Romney would win the Republican nomination and probably go on to win the general, but if for whatever reason Reagan did win the Presidency in '68, I see things going something like this:

37. Ronald Reagan (Republican): 1969-1973
38. Eugene McCarthy (Democrat): 1973-1981
39. Bob Dole (Republican): 1981-1989
40. Mario Cuomo (Democrat): 1989-1997
41. Bill Clinton (Democrat): 1997-2001
42. John McCain (Republican): 2001-2009
43. Barack Obama (Democrat):2009-2017
44. Hillary Clinton (Democrat): 2017-2021
45. Rand Paul (Republican): 2021-?
 
I highly doubt the GOP would hold the White House for 25 years, and I doubt that Ronald Reagan would get elected President or even get the GOP nomination due to the fact that he was only governor of California for less than 2 years (he was elected in 1966). If Nixon didn't run in 1968, or messed up bad enough to where he would lose the nomination, Nelson Rockefeller or George Romney would win the Republican nomination and probably go on to win the general, but if for whatever reason Reagan did win the Presidency in '68, I see things going something like this:

37. Ronald Reagan (Republican): 1969-1973
38. Eugene McCarthy (Democrat): 1973-1981
39. Bob Dole (Republican): 1981-1989
40. Mario Cuomo (Democrat): 1989-1997
41. Bill Clinton (Democrat): 1997-2001
42. John McCain (Republican): 2001-2009
43. Barack Obama (Democrat):2009-2017
44. Hillary Clinton (Democrat): 2017-2021
45. Rand Paul (Republican): 2021-?
Eugene McCarthy was way too out there to win the presidency. Maybe he could win the Democratic nomination like McGovern (though he would be even weaker than McGovern, and McGovern would probably steal most of his support like in OTL), but in the general he would go down even worse than McGovern. Otherwise a fairly solid list.

That was the only one that I thought of for Theodore Roosevelt.
Why not... any other Democrat in the United States?
 
I highly doubt the GOP would hold the White House for 25 years, and I doubt that Ronald Reagan would get elected President or even get the GOP nomination due to the fact that he was only governor of California for less than 2 years (he was elected in 1966). If Nixon didn't run in 1968, or messed up bad enough to where he would lose the nomination, Nelson Rockefeller or George Romney would win the Republican nomination and probably go on to win the general, but if for whatever reason Reagan did win the Presidency in '68, I see things going something like this:

37. Ronald Reagan (Republican): 1969-1973
38. Eugene McCarthy (Democrat): 1973-1981
39. Bob Dole (Republican): 1981-1989
40. Mario Cuomo (Democrat): 1989-1997
41. Bill Clinton (Democrat): 1997-2001
42. John McCain (Republican): 2001-2009
43. Barack Obama (Democrat):2009-2017
44. Hillary Clinton (Democrat): 2017-2021
45. Rand Paul (Republican): 2021-?

Come on, not even one OTL minor politician or "could've been"?
 
List if Cheney declined to be Bush's VEEP. Big butterflies are no Iraq War (the likes of Danforth and Powell get Bush's ear) and a later economic downturn.

2001-2005: George W. Bush (Republican-Texas) / John Danforth (Republican-Missouri)
2000: Al Gore (D-TN)/Joe Lieberman (D-CT), Ralph Nader (G-CT)/Winona LaDuke (G-MN)
2005-2009: John Edwards (Democratic-North Carolina) / Joe Biden (Democratic-Delaware)
2004: George W. Bush (R-TX)/John Danforth (R-MO)
2009-2013: Jeb Bush (Republican-Florida) / Colin Powell (Republican-New York)
2008: John Edwards (D-NC)/Joe Biden (D-DE), Matt Gonzalez (G-CA)/Pat LaMarche (G-ME)
2013-Current: Hillary Rodham-Clinton (Democratic-New York) / Mark Warner (Democratic-Virginia)
2012: Jeb Bush (R-FL)/Colin Powell (R-NY), Wesley Clark (I-AR)/Chris Daggett (I-NJ)
 

Japhy

Banned
There's no breaking the Obama Constant.

Thanks there, Paul.

Frankly while I don't think Reagan-running-as-Goldwater-1968 would be a success, I have sincere doubts that the Democrats would swing all the way to designated loser McCarthy. Hell McGovern wouldn't even have a chance when 1972 is seen as a race to win.
 
No Chappaquiddick

1969-1973: Richard Nixon (R-CA)/Spiro Agnew (R-MD)
1968:Hubert Humphrey (D-MN)/Edmund Muskie (D-ME), George Wallace (A-AL)/Curtis LeMay(A-CA)
1973-1981: Edward M. Kennedy (D-MA)/Terry Sanford (D-NC)
1973:
Richard Nixon (R-CA)/Spiro Agnew (R-MD)
1976: Ronald Reagan (R-CA)/Richard Schweiker (R-PA)
1981-1989: George H.W. Bush (R-TX)/Jack Kemp (R-NY)
1980: Terry Sanford (D-NC)/Walter Mondale (D-MN)
1984:
Walter Mondale (D-MN)/Dale Bumpers (D-AR)
1989-1993: Jack Kemp (R-NY)/Lamar Alexander (R-TN)
1988:
Dick Gephardt (D-MO)/Michael Dukakis (D-MA)
1993-2001: Bill Bradley (D-NJ)/Bill Clinton (D-AR)
1992:
Jack Kemp (R-NY)/Lamar Alexander (R-TN)
1996:
Lamar Alexander (R-TN)/Tommy Thompson (R-WI)
2001-2009:
Tommy Thompson (R-WI)/J.C. Watts (R-OK)
2000: Bill Clinton (D-AR)/John Kerry (D-MA)
2004:
Paul Wellstone (D-MN)/John Edwards (D-NC)
2009-2017: Shannon O'Brien (D-MA)/Mark Warner (D-VA)

2008: J.C. Watts (R-OK)/ Charlie Crist (R-FL)
2012: Jeb Bush (R-FL)/Tim Pawlanty (R-MN)

 
'Lavenderesk'

2000-2008: George W. Bush/Dick Cheney (Republican)[1]
2008-2012: Hilary Clinton/Evan Bayh (Democratic)[2]
2012-2014: Rick Santorum/John McCain (Republican)[3]
2014-2016: John McCain/vacant (Republican)[4]
2016-2024: Marco Rubio/Lisa Murkowski (Republican)[5]
2024-2028: Arnold Schwarzenegger/Rand Paul (Republican)[6]
2028-2032: Gwen Graham/Chelsea Clinton (Democratic)[7]
2032-2036: Arnold Schwarzenegger/Steve Harrison (Republican)[8]
2036-2039: Lincoln Matthews/Elizabeth Hughes (Democratic)[9]
2039-????: Rumsfeld DeLeon Brookes (American Section of the Fourth International)

[1] At the neoconservative dream there is the notion of perpetual revolution, world wide revolution, notions that share a lot with Trotskyism. Global socialism may have failed in 1991, but her secret adherents had plans for America and the world...
[2] It was a close run thing, but the Clinton/Bayh ticket achieved victory, mostly sticking to the Republican consensus in the Middle East, mostly out of a desire to fix what they'd broken. Dissatisfaction with the Democrats, particularly over foreign policy and the economy grew over the four years.
[3] A palaeoconservative got elected, a man who promised to do what was needed to fix the economy, bring our boys back home, and put America back on the straight and narrow. He polarised the country because of his religious beliefs but his more pragmatic VP was able to paper over some of these cracks. Perhaps it was because of McCain what happened next, happened at all.
[4] Santorum was shot and killed by what was later identified as a lone gunman while making a speech in New York. McCain assumed the presidency, while speculation swirled about the nature of the president's death. McCain brought American arms back into Iraq, this time fighting the Islamic State. The economy was limping and domestic unrest was at a new high thanks to a paranoid and heavy-handed security apparatus.
[5] The neoconservative agenda continued, moderated by increasingly social liberal Murkowski. With the Democrats in disarray, Rubio was able to unleash a new wave of 'nation-building', a campaign which led to increased instability, isolation, and state spending. However, the neoconservative commitment to a form of welfare state ensured their popularity.
[6] Schwarzenegger was able to plead his case to the Supreme Court, and began to bring the army home. However, the soldiers returning to America had been radicalised and disillusioned by years of fighting for corporate interests as well as ideological ones, and this was worsened by watching the lands they had conquered fall into disarray, and in some cases direct corporate rule.
[7] Schwarzenegger had a large personal vote, but the voters had become fatigued. The Democrats achieved victory, just in time for the balloon to go up in Russia, as they tried pull a Ukraine in the Baltic. Thankfully, things didn't go nuclear, but American troops ended up being deployed again, this time by a Democratic administration. Crucially, this time they actually achieved victory. American troops stayed long enough to see the Communists elected in a landslide and the Second Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic born. The experience of fighting alongside Communists played into the hands of those who had been directing America's destiny since the early 2000s.
[8] The elderly statesman returned triumphant, with the Democrats marred by an economic crisis and the foreign adventure in Russia that had seen the Soviet Union reborn at least in part. Schwarzenegger cut the military budget, in an attempt to balance the books, but now there were unemployed ex-soldiers. Schwarzenegger's last term was also marred by the mess of Central and South Asia.
[9] With violence out of control in the inner cities and the PATRIOT Act put to full use on domestic soil, brigades of unemployed soldiers now fencing off streets from a militarised police force, and the red flag being flown from many city halls, the entire situation was about to collapse. A narrow Democratic victory, as conservatives voted for a candidate who promised law and order, and liberals voted for someone who promised to restore peace and harmony, proved hollow. The Matthews Administration was overthrown after three years. As the flag of the Fourth International was raised above Washington, the shadow master behind the revolution revealed himself, or at least his successor was.
 
Top
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top